Northrop XP-56 Black Bullet
The Northrop XP-56 Black Bullet was an experimental single-seat fighter-interceptor built by the Northrop Corporation during the Second World War. It was one of the most radical experimental aircraft of the conflict: a tailless, near all-wing layout, a short central fuselage housing the pilot and a pusher engine driving contra-rotating propellers, and an airframe built almost entirely of magnesium alloy. Only two prototypes were built. Plagued by stability and control problems and with disappointing performance, the type never entered production.
Design and development
In the summer of 1939, the United States Army Air Corps began drafting the requirements for a new high-performance fighter, and on 17 July 1939 the Assistant Secretary of War released funds for unconventional single-seat fighter designs. The specification, frozen in September 1939, called for a top speed of about 850 km/h (525 mph) at 4,500 m (15,000 ft). It was issued in February 1940 as "Request for Data R-40C". Thirteen manufacturers were invited and seven submitted proposals. Vultee was ranked first, ahead of Curtiss-Wright and Northrop, and three prototypes were ordered under the designations XP-54, XP-55 and XP-56.
The initial idea for the XP-56 was quite radical for 1939. Jack Northrop, fascinated by the flying wing concept since the late 1920s, saw in the competition an opportunity to apply it to a fighter. His N-2 design, studied in several versions (N-2 to N-2D) differing in engine and armament, had no horizontal tail and only a small vertical fin, a short and stubby fuselage, and a large ventral fin. It was to be powered by Pratt & Whitney's experimental liquid-cooled X-1800 engine, buried in the fuselage behind the pilot and driving two contra-rotating propellers in a pusher arrangement, with the engine air intakes located in the wing roots. The Army authorized the first phase of development (engineering data and wind tunnel models) on 22 June 1940, and ordered a prototype in September 1940.
When development of the X-1800 was stopped, the Pratt & Whitney R-2800 Double Wasp radial, which was not yet fully developed, was substituted. Although more powerful (2,000 hp vs 1,800 hp), it was larger in diameter and required a wider fuselage. The new engine was expected to add about 2,000 lb (910 kg) and cost 14 mph (23 km/h) in top speed.
To evaluate the tailless configuration, Northrop relied on its N-1M flying wing, a small test aircraft powered by two Lycoming engines, whose wing was very similar to the one planned for the XP-56. These flight trials confirmed the stability of the radical layout and, upon review, the Army ordered a second prototype on 13 February 1942.
Because aluminum was forecast to be in short supply due to wartime demands, Northrop built the airframe and skin of the XP-56 from magnesium alloy. At the time there was little experience with magnesium aircraft construction, and the metal cannot be riveted like steel or aluminum. A team including Vladimir Pavlecka, Tom Piper and Russell Meredith developed an inert-gas shielded arc welding process for magnesium, known as "Heliarc". Northrop obtained a patent only on the welding torch, General Electric having already patented the process. The XP-56 is considered the first aircraft built almost entirely of magnesium.
The mid-mounted wing had a leading-edge sweep of 26° and drooping outer panels. Elevons on the inner wing acted as both ailerons and elevators, while split "drag rudders" in the outer panels provided yaw control. The aircraft had a tricycle landing gear. As it had no ejection seat, Pratt & Whitney fitted an explosive cord around the propeller gearbox, so that the propellers could be blown off before the pilot bailed out. The planned armament of two 20 mm cannon and four .50 in (12.7 mm) machine guns in the nose was never installed.
Operational history
The first prototype (s/n 41-786) was delivered to Muroc Army Air Base, California, in March 1943. The first engine runs, in late March 1943, failed because of excessive flexing of the propeller shafts, which damaged the engine. Pratt & Whitney did not send another engine until August, causing a five-month delay. Taxi tests of the XP-56 began on 6 April 1943 and showed a serious yaw problem. At first it was thought to be caused by uneven wheel brakes, and manual brakes were installed.
On 6 September 1943, test pilot John Myers made a first hop of about 30 seconds a few feet above the dry lake, noting the instability of the aircraft. The first real flight took place on 30 September 1943. The yaw problem was found to be due to insufficient directional stability, and the upper vertical fin was enlarged to roughly the size of the ventral fin. On 8 October 1943, during a high-speed taxi run with the landing gear doors removed, the tire on the left main gear blew out. The aircraft tumbled end over end and was destroyed. Myers survived, crediting his escape to the polo player's helmet he had decided to wear. Myers was the test pilot for several of Northrop's radical designs during the war.
The second prototype (s/n 42-38353) was not completed until January 1944. It had been re-ballasted to move the center of gravity forward, fitted with a much larger dorsal fin, reworked rudder linkages and new tires. It first flew on 23 March 1944 with Harry Crosby at the controls: a flight of about ten minutes, climbing to about 2,500 ft (750 m) at 180 mph (290 km/h), during which the pilot had to fight very heavy stick forces and a very sensitive rudder. Pilots later reported difficulty in lifting the nose wheel at take-off, extreme sensitivity in yaw, tail heaviness, a lack of power and high fuel consumption.
After six flights it was clear that the XP-56 would not meet the requirements. It reached at best about 340 mph (547 km/h) and 20,000 ft (6,000 m), against the 465 mph (750 km/h) at 25,000 ft (7,600 m) expected, a performance inferior to that of the Republic P-47 Thunderbolt already in service. Wind tunnel tests at the NACA Ames laboratory were proposed but postponed. On the ninth flight, pilot Alex Papana damaged the ventral fin on landing, and the tenth flight, on 11 August 1944, showed no improvement. The Army Air Forces then grounded the aircraft, as further flights were judged too hazardous. In all, the XP-56 had flown only 5 hours and 55 minutes.
Wind tunnel tests were scheduled for June 1945 and the aircraft was moved to Moffett Field to await them, but they never took place. Northrop's attention had turned to its XB-35 flying wing bomber, and by 1946 the Army Air Forces had moved on to jet fighters. The reasons why the XP-56 flew so poorly were never fully determined.
Aircraft on display
- 41-786 : first prototype, destroyed in a high-speed taxi accident at Muroc on 8 October 1943.
- 42-38353 : second prototype. On 20 December 1946, the Army Air Forces shipped it with other Second World War aircraft to Park Ridge, Illinois, for storage. In 1950-1951, the collection moved to Suitland, Maryland, and the aircraft became part of the National Air and Space Museum collection. It is kept at the Paul E. Garber Preservation, Restoration and Storage Facility in Suitland.
Variants
- N-2, N-2A, N-2B, N-2C, N-2D : design studies with various engines (Pratt & Whitney X-1800, R-2800 and R-1830, Allison V-1710) and armament combinations.
- XP-56 : two prototypes built, serials 41-786 (destroyed in 1943) and 42-38353 (preserved).
Operators
- United States : United States Army Air Forces (tests only).
Aircraft of comparable role, configuration and era
References
- Allen, R.S. The Northrop Story. New York: Orion, 1990. ISBN 0-517-56677-X.
- Allen, Francis J. "Northrop's Failed Fighter: The Story of the XP-56 and its Flying-Wing Design". Air Enthusiast, No. 32, December 1986.
- Andersen, Fred. Northrop: An Aeronautical History. Century City, California: Northrop Corporation, 1976.
- Balzer, Gerald H. American Secret Pusher Fighters of World War II: XP-54, XP-55, and XP-56. North Branch, Minnesota: Specialty Press, 2008. ISBN 1-58007-125-2.
- Goldstein, Richard. "John Myers, 96, World War II Test Pilot, Is Dead". The New York Times, 10 February 2008.
- Jenkins, Dennis R. and Tony Landis. Experimental and Prototype U.S. Air Force Jet Fighters. North Branch, Minnesota: Specialty Press, 2008.
- Maloney, Edward T. Northrop Flying Wings. Buena Park, California: Planes of Fame Publishers, 1975. ISBN 0-915464-00-4.
- National Air and Space Museum. "Northrop XP-56 Black Bullet" (inventory number A19600303000).
- Pape, Gerry, John M. Campbell and Donna Campbell. The Flying Wings of Jack Northrop. Atglen, Pennsylvania: Schiffer, 1994.
- Wooldridge, E.T. Winged Wonders: The Story of the Flying Wings. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Press, 1983. ISBN 0-87474-966-2.
— — — = = — — —